THA-C05 · source internal or version conflict
Classification and audit outcome: source internal or version conflict; supported.
Finding
Published abstract says 21 people failed. Accepted-manuscript tables tally 7 and 14 failed occasions across preoperative assessments; unique-person overlap is not established. Manuscript interrater values also differ from final abstract.
Current amendment or qualification
The published abstract reports 21 preoperative failures. Accepted-manuscript Tables 2–3 enumerate failed test occasions across assessments, so the number of unique unsuccessful participants and handling of unsuccessful timed trials require reconciliation. Retain published-abstract interrater LoA rather than silently substituting the differing manuscript values.
Integration note: Preserve both accounts and version labels; do not convert summed failures to 21 unique participants.
Remaining limitation: Final-version tables still needed.
Evidence and provenance
- Reliability and validity of the Four Square Step Test in patients with hip osteoarthritis before and after total hip replacement. · Original source
Affected reports
Original audit locator(s): P38; P58; P185
Audit corrections describe the report only where that classification is explicit. A disagreement within a study, missing protocol, statistical query, access upgrade or optional addition is not silently converted into a report error or a new clinical threshold.
Audit register · Unresolved evidence queue
Linked knowledge pages
- COND-THA Total hip arthroplasty
- DOMAIN-BALANCE Standing balance
Located in this vault
- Standing balance assessment and prognosis after total hip arthroplasty: P0038, P0058, P0185, P0055, P0056, P0057
Mapping status: exact. An exact location match is not an additional empirical verification.